Fracking Fights Loom Large in Mexico – Part IV

This week, we conclude our four-part guest series on hydraulic fracturing in Mexico written by Frontera NorteSur, Center for Latin American and Border Studies, New Mexico State University, Las Cruces, New Mexico.  We thank the Center for permission to publish their work.

TransLegal works extensively with companies doing business in Mexico in sectors that include issues such as biodiversity, biotechnology, cosmetics, energy, foods and pharmaceuticals.  Call us with your questions concerning Mexico.

Frontera NorteSur

Mexican opponents of the controversial method of extracting natural gas known as fracking lost an important battle in the Mexican Senate last month. As part of a 91-26 vote that approved secondary legislation implementing the Peña Nieto administration’s energy reform, most senators rejected a measure that would have prohibited fracking.


Mexican Coat of Arms  Photo Credit:  Alex Covarrubias via Wikimedia Commons

Mexican Coat of Arms
Photo Credit: Alex Covarrubias via Wikimedia Commons

Prior to the July 18, 2014 vote, the Mexican Alliance against Fracking, a grouping of environmental organizations, presented senators with a petition signed by more than 10,000 people that supported a fracking ban.


Nonetheless, a majority of senators from President Peña Nieto’s PRI party joined with lawmakers from the PAN and PVEM (Mexican Green) parties to reject an outright prohibition of fracking. Voting in favor of a ban were members of the PRD and PT parties.


Senator Pablo Escudero, PVEM representative, maintained that environmental studies in the United States, as well as the history of fracking in Texas, Louisiana, New Mexico and other states, showed that fracking could be done in a safe manner. To back up his case, Escudero referred to studies by University of California physicist Dr. Richard Muller, whose pro-environment arguments in favor of fracking have engendered sharp polemics.


Taking a stand against outlawing fracking in Mexico, PAN Senator Silvia Garza of Coahuila, who represents a state where large deposits of shale gas are said to be located, declared that economic development could not be stopped.


Mexican Senate  Photo Credit: Pit Bull Terrier via Wikimedia Commons

Mexican Senate
Photo Credit: Pit Bull Terrier via Wikimedia Commons

“I am against overregulation,” Garza said. “I am against the brake they want to put on this country.”


Chihuahua Senator Javier Corral, also a member of the PAN, begged to differ from the majority of his colleagues.


“One cannot affect the viability of the planet in the name of economic development,” Corral said. “(Fracking) will have devastating consequences in the state of Chihuahua, from the intensive use of water and its contamination, and from methane emissions that produce 21 times more greenhouse gases than does carbon dioxide.”


Corral continued, “Over there (Chihuahua), where rain is not plentiful, how will they bring the (water) necessary for drilling a well?”


Fracking proponents earlier got a boost from a prominent figure known for his environmental advocacy-Nobel Chemistry Prize winner Mario Molina.


Mexican Senate  Photo Credit: LuisS via Wikimedia Commons

Mexican Senate
Photo Credit: LuisS via Wikimedia Commons

In a recent comments to the Mexican press, Molina gave a qualified endorsement to fracking, saying it was a viable proposition as long as it was “done right.” Like Senator Escudero, Molina pointed to the United States (where opposition to fracking is growing), adding that enhanced gas exploitation had brought economic benefits.


“Let’s do it as it is done in the U.S.,” Molina said. “It varies a lot from state to state, but some are doing it very well. If it is not done right, it won’t last long. It’s being stopped in many countries.”


Passed in the Senate, the energy reform legislation, minus the anti-fracking measure, was sent to the lower house of the Mexican Congress for approval. Meanwhile, the Mexican Alliance against Fracking vowed to keep fighting against the extraction of shale gas. According a message posted on the activist group’s Facebook page, an additional 13,000 people signed the anti-fracking petition after it was delivered to senators last week.



Sources: El Mexicano/El Sol de Mexico, July 19, 2014. Article by Bertha Becerrra. La Jornada, July 17 and July 19, 2014. Articles by Emir Olivares, Andrea Becerril and Enrique Mendez., July 18, 2014. Article by Angelica Mercado and Omar Brito. Proceso/Apro, July 17, 2014. Article by Jenaro Villamil. El Universal, May 19 and July, 2014.  Articles by Adriana Vallinas,  Alberto Morales and Juan Arvizu.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s